← All news
Global · Policy / Regulation
Global·Policy / Regulation

EU court adviser says Google's AI summaries can infringe publishers' copyright

Advocate General Maciej Szpunar says AI-generated summaries can breach publishers' copyright in some circumstances. His advice also says paywalls cannot be bypassed to obtain material for AI answers.

AI Hubs United Editorial ·

Google's AI search summaries can infringe news publishers' copyright in some circumstances, according to an opinion reported by NOS. Advocate General Maciej Szpunar issued the advice to the Court of Justice of the European Union in a case brought by a Hungarian media company against Alphabet, Google's parent company. Google uses Gemini to assemble its AI Overviews from multiple online sources.

According to NOS's account of the opinion, copyright permits the reuse of reported facts, but AI must express them in different words. Rewording a publication retrieved from a website can nevertheless infringe copyright in some cases, Szpunar says. His advice also states that bypassing a paywall to obtain information or text for an AI answer is not permitted. These positions are an adviser's opinion, rather than a final judgment in the case.

The dispute has practical implications for publishers dependent on search referrals. NOS cites Reuters research finding that people seeking news information rarely follow the source links displayed alongside Google's summaries. The report links declining traffic to fewer subscribers and lower advertising revenue, reducing the money available for journalism.

AI Hubs United original short summary of the source linked above. It is not the original article; read the full story at the source.